China is attempting to paralyse the research of Professor Laura Murphy at the UK’s Sheffield Hallam University. The research focuses on the forced labour of Uyghur Muslims (a Turkic-speaking Muslim ethnic minority in China’s Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region) in China’s northwestern Xinjiang region.
The practice of pressure from the Chinese side has been ongoing for two years, including contacts with individual university staff members by individuals who identified themselves as representatives of China’s national security service. A significant fact is that access to the university’s website was also blocked from China.
The United Kingdom views this issue not only as a serious violation of human rights but has also classified the events as a breach of state sovereignty and national interest. Despite this, the university suspended the research after two years of pressure.
The role of the university administration itself is also a critical factor, as its directives prevented Professor Murphy from continuing her research process on the forced labour of Muslims. The professor initiated legal action against the university, citing the violation of her individual academic freedom.
“The university administration directly negotiated with a foreign intelligence service. They traded the professor’s academic freedom for the renewal of website access,” stated Professor Murphy.
It is important to note that many Chinese students continued their studies at the university, and naturally, this process was halted after the website access was restricted.
The Chinese Embassy in London informed the BBC that “the Helena Kennedy Centre at Sheffield Hallam University published a report containing false information on Xinjiang.” The Embassy further alleged that “some authors of these reports were found to have received funding from US agencies.” Professor Murphy, speaking to the BBC, confirmed she received funding from the US National Endowment for the Humanities, which was intended to produce an autobiographical account from individuals involved in forced labour.
The pressure reached an active phase in 2024. On April 18, 2024, “three officers from the national security service” visited the Sheffield Hallam office in China. A two-hour interrogation ensued regarding the future and current research of the Helena Kennedy Centre for International Justice (HKC), as Professor Murphy was conducting her research under the HKC’s auspices.
This came after the Centre published a December 2023 study exposing the exploitation of individuals in the garment manufacturing and supply process in the Xinjiang region. The report named the Hong Kong-based company Smart Shirts Ltd, which subsequently filed a libel lawsuit against the university. The London High Court issued a preliminary finding that the report indeed contained financially damaging content for the company, though the validity of the underlying information was not questioned. Professor Murphy’s reputation is globally significant. Her research was highly regarded by the UK, Canada, and Australia parliaments, and often served as a basis for policy recommendations. In 2023, Murphy worked at the US Department of Homeland Security, participating in the implementation of the Uyghur Forced Labour Prevention Act. She has consistently focused on researching forced labour practices throughout these years.
During her absence, Sheffield Hallam University decided in August 2024 to discontinue the research project on forced labour, despite the project still being externally funded. Murphy was informed of this decision upon her return. The university validated its decision by citing pressure from security services, arguing that the safety of staff members in both the UK and China was at risk. To resolve the issue, it is vital to consider the valid arguments of both sides. The Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023 mandates universities to protect the academic freedom of students and professors, which primarily includes freedom of speech.
For Murphy, the university traded her personal freedom for commercial interests. However, university representatives stated that Chinese students were never a primary market for Sheffield Hallam, as only 73 students from China were recorded in the 2024–2025 academic year. Meanwhile, the Chinese Embassy noted that over 200,000 Chinese students study in the UK. Baroness Helena Kennedy, who is herself sanctioned by China over her Xinjiang statements, observed that due to financial crises, British universities have become dependent on the revenue from Chinese students, making them vulnerable to Chinese pressure.
Author: Mariam Arabashvili
